Skip to main content

Email Compliance: CAN-SPAM, GDPR, and More

🎚️

Adjust Technical Level

Select your expertise level to customize content

Email marketing compliance encompasses adhering to various regional and international legal frameworks governing electronic commercial communications. These regulations establish requirements for obtaining consent, maintaining subscriber preferences, providing unsubscribe mechanisms, identifying senders, and securing personal data. Implementing comprehensive compliance protocols is crucial for avoiding penalties, maintaining deliverability, and fostering recipient trust.

CAN-SPAM Act Explained​

Technical Implementation

Technical

What CAN-SPAM Means for Your Business

The CAN-SPAM Act is the main email marketing law in the United States. It's not just for bulk email – it covers all commercial messages, which the law defines as "any electronic mail message the primary purpose of which is the commercial advertisement or promotion of a commercial product or service."

What Your Business Needs to Do:

  • Be Honest in the "From" Line: Use a real person or company name that recipients will recognize
  • Write Accurate Subject Lines: Don't mislead people about what's in your email
  • Identify Advertisements: Make it clear when your message is an ad
  • Include Your Business Address: Every email needs your valid physical postal address
  • Make Unsubscribing Easy: Provide a clear way to opt out that works for at least 30 days after sending
  • Honor Unsubscribes Promptly: Stop sending emails within 10 business days when someone opts out
  • Know What Others Do in Your Name: Even if you hire another company to handle your email marketing, you're legally responsible for compliance

Business Risks of Non-Compliance:

  • Financial Penalties: Each violation is subject to fines of up to $46,517
  • Reputation Damage: Non-compliant practices can harm your brand reputation
  • Deliverability Issues: Email service providers may block your messages
  • Customer Trust: Poor email practices erode customer confidence

Business Benefits of Compliance:

  • Better Deliverability: Following best practices improves inbox placement
  • Increased Trust: Transparent practices build recipient confidence
  • Higher Engagement: Sending only to those who want your emails improves metrics
  • Lower Costs: Maintaining clean lists reduces sending costs

Business Implications

Non-Technical

CAN-SPAM Act Technical Requirements

The CAN-SPAM Act (Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography And Marketing) is a U.S. federal law established in 2003 that sets requirements for commercial email messages and gives recipients the right to have you stop emailing them.

Technical Implementation Requirements:

  • Header Information: All routing information (From, To, Reply-To fields and routing information in the header) must be accurate and identify the person or business who initiated the message
  • Subject Lines: Subject line must accurately reflect the content of the message (non-deceptive)
  • Identification: Message must clearly identify itself as an advertisement unless the recipient has given prior consent to receive the message
  • Physical Location: Must include the valid physical postal address of the sender
  • Unsubscribe Mechanism: Must include a clear and conspicuous opt-out mechanism that remains functional for at least 30 days after the message is sent
  • Opt-Out Processing: Must honor opt-out requests within 10 business days
  • List Management: Cannot sell or transfer email addresses of individuals who have opted out
  • Monitoring Agents: You're responsible for compliance even if you hire another company to handle your email marketing

Technical Implementation Strategies:

  • SMTP Headers: Ensure all SMTP headers are accurate and non-deceptive
  • Authentication: Implement proper email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) to verify sender identity
  • List Database Design: Build unsubscribe functionality into subscriber database with timestamp tracking
  • Preference Center: Create a comprehensive preference center to manage opt-outs
  • API Integration: Implement real-time API calls to process unsubscribes across systems
  • Suppression Lists: Maintain master suppression lists across all sending platforms
  • Logging: Record all opt-out requests with timestamps for compliance verification
  • Templates: Build required elements (physical address, unsubscribe mechanism) into all email templates

GDPR and Email Marketing​

GDPR and Your Email Marketing Program

What is GDPR?

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is a comprehensive data privacy law that took effect in 2018 and applies to the processing of personal data of individuals in the European Union (EU) and European Economic Area (EEA), regardless of where your business is located.

Key GDPR Principles for Email Marketing:

  1. Explicit Consent: You need clear permission before sending marketing emails
    • No pre-checked boxes on signup forms
    • Clear explanation of what they're signing up for
    • Separate consent for different types of communications
  2. Detailed Records: Keep evidence of how and when consent was obtained
    • Date and time of signup
    • Which form or page they used
    • What exactly they agreed to receive
  3. Right to Be Forgotten: Honor requests to delete personal data
    • Completely remove contact information when requested
    • Document the deletion process
  4. Data Access Rights: Provide individuals with their data upon request
    • Be able to export all data you have about a person
    • Explain how you're using their information
  5. Privacy Notices: Clearly explain your data practices
    • What data you collect
    • Why you collect it
    • How long you keep it
    • Who you share it with

Business Impact of GDPR:

  • Smaller but Better Lists: You may have fewer contacts, but they'll be more engaged
  • Improved Trust: Transparent practices build stronger customer relationships
  • Higher Engagement: People who explicitly opt in are more likely to engage with your emails
  • Significant Penalties: Non-compliance can result in fines up to €20 million or 4% of global annual revenue, whichever is higher
  • Global Impact: Even if you're not in the EU, you need to comply if you have EU subscribers

Practical Steps for Compliance:

  • Review and update all signup forms to ensure explicit consent
  • Create a comprehensive preference center where subscribers can manage their choices
  • Implement processes to handle data access and deletion requests
  • Update your privacy policy to clearly explain your email marketing practices
  • Train your marketing team on GDPR requirements
  • Regularly audit your email marketing practices for ongoing compliance

DMARC, SPF, and DKIM​

100%
🔍 Use Ctrl+Scroll to zoom
Sends emailChecksVerifiesSPF RecordDKIM KeysDMARC PolicySPF ResultDKIM ResultIf aligned & passedIf failedDeliverBased on policySendingMail ServerDNSRecordsReceivingMail ServerSPF CheckDKIM CheckDMARC PolicyEnforcementAuthenticationPassedAuthenticationFailedDeliveredto InboxQuarantinedor Rejected

Legend

Components
Sending Side
DNS Infrastructure
Receiving Side
Authentication
Authentication Result
Delivery Outcome
Connection Types
Process Flow
Sends email
Checks
Verifies

Sender Policy Framework (SPF)

What SPF Does for Your Email

SPF is like a guest list for your domain's email. It tells receiving email servers which mail servers are allowed to send email using your domain name.

Why SPF Matters:
  • Prevents Spoofing: Makes it harder for spammers to send emails pretending to be from your domain
  • Improves Deliverability: Emails with valid SPF records are less likely to be marked as spam
  • Protects Brand Reputation: Reduces the chance your domain gets blacklisted due to spoofing
In Simple Terms:

Think of SPF as an ID check at a secure building:

  1. You (the domain owner) give a list of authorized visitors (mail servers) to the security guard (DNS)
  2. When someone (an email) arrives claiming to be from your company, the receiving mail server checks with security
  3. If the sender is on the approved list, they're allowed in
  4. If not, they're either turned away or flagged as suspicious
Business Implementation Steps:
  1. Inventory Your Sending Sources: Make a list of all services that send email on behalf of your domain (marketing platforms, CRM, support desk, etc.)
  2. Create Your SPF Record: Work with your IT team or DNS provider to create and publish an SPF record
  3. Test Your Record: Use SPF validation tools to ensure your record is correctly formatted
  4. Monitor Performance: Watch for delivery issues after implementation and adjust if needed
Common Pitfalls to Avoid:
  • Forgetting Senders: Missing legitimate email sources in your SPF record
  • Too Strict Too Soon: Setting a strict policy before testing thoroughly
  • Neglecting Updates: Not updating your SPF record when adding new email service providers

Global Email Regulations Comparison​

Regulation
Region
Consent Requirement
Unsubscribe Requirement
Sender Identification
Key Penalties
CAN-SPAM ActUnited StatesOpt-out (no prior consent required)Clear mechanism that works for at least 30 days; must be processed within 10 business daysMust include valid physical address; accurate header informationUp to $46,517 per violation
GDPREuropean UnionOpt-in (explicit consent required before sending)Clear mechanism to withdraw consent at any timeIdentity of sender must be clear; purpose of processing must be transparentUp to €20 million or 4% of annual global turnover, whichever is higher
CASLCanadaOpt-in (express or implied consent required before sending)Clear mechanism that works for at least 60 days; must be processed within 10 business daysMust identify sender and include valid physical address and contact informationUp to CAD $10 million for organizations; CAD $1 million for individuals
PECRUnited KingdomOpt-in (explicit consent required, with limited B2B exceptions)Clear mechanism to opt out of future communicationsMust identify sender and provide contact detailsUp to £500,000 (ICO); can be higher under UK GDPR
ePrivacy DirectiveEuropean UnionOpt-in (explicit consent required, with limited B2B exceptions in some countries)Clear and simple way to refuse future communicationsMust clearly identify commercial nature and sender identityVaries by EU member state
PDPASingaporeOpt-in (consent required) or existing business relationshipClear unsubscribe option in every messageMust include sender information and contact detailsUp to SGD $1 million
Anti-Spam LawAustraliaOpt-in (express or inferred consent required)Functional unsubscribe mechanism that works for at least 30 daysMust include sender information and contact detailsUp to AUD $2.1 million per day for organizations
LGPDBrazilOpt-in (explicit consent required unless another legal basis applies)Must provide ability to revoke consent easilyMust clearly identify the controller and data processing informationUp to 2% of revenue in Brazil (capped at R$50 million per violation)
POPI ActSouth AfricaOpt-in (consent required unless another justification applies)Must provide option to withdraw consent or opt outMust identify sender and provide contact detailsUp to 10 million Rand or imprisonment

Implementing Compliant Email Programs​

Building a Compliant Email Marketing Program

Essential Elements of Email Compliance

  1. Get Proper Permission
    • Use unchecked checkboxes for consent
    • Be specific about what they're signing up for
    • Keep records of how and when people subscribed
    • Consider double opt-in (confirmation email) for stronger proof
    • Get separate permission for different types of emails
  2. Make Unsubscribing Easy
    • Include a clear unsubscribe link in every email
    • Don't require login or passwords to unsubscribe
    • Process opt-outs quickly (within 10 days, but immediately is best)
    • Consider a preference center to retain partial communication
    • Never charge a fee to unsubscribe
  3. Identify Yourself Clearly
    • Use accurate "From" names that recipients will recognize
    • Include your business name in the email
    • Add your physical address to every email
    • Provide clear contact information
    • Implement email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)
  4. Be Transparent in Content
    • Use honest subject lines that reflect email content
    • Identify advertisements as such
    • Clearly disclose if content is sponsored
    • Be upfront about how you got their information
    • Include links to your privacy policy
  5. Maintain Clean Lists
    • Regularly remove unengaged subscribers
    • Process bounces and update your list
    • Honor unsubscribes across all systems
    • Don't buy or rent email lists
    • Implement a sunset policy for inactive subscribers

Implementing a Compliance Program

  1. Assess Your Current State
    • Review how you're collecting email addresses
    • Examine your existing email templates
    • Check how unsubscribes are processed
    • Evaluate your database for consent records
    • Identify which regulations apply to your audience
  2. Update Your Processes
    • Revise signup forms to meet consent requirements
    • Create or improve your preference center
    • Standardize email templates with required elements
    • Implement proper authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)
    • Create a suppression list management process
  3. Train Your Team
    • Educate marketing staff on compliance requirements
    • Create clear guidelines for email marketing
    • Establish approval workflows for campaigns
    • Designate compliance officers or champions
    • Schedule regular refresher training
  4. Implement Monitoring
    • Track complaint rates by campaign
    • Monitor unsubscribe processing times
    • Conduct regular compliance audits
    • Test unsubscribe functionality regularly
    • Review sender authentication reports
  5. Create Documentation
    • Document your compliance policy
    • Maintain consent records
    • Keep records of compliance reviews
    • Create a data breach response plan
    • Update your privacy policy as needed

Compliance Checklist for Every Email Campaign

  • ☐ Sending only to people who have given proper consent
  • ☐ Clear, recognizable sender name
  • ☐ Honest, non-deceptive subject line
  • ☐ Functional unsubscribe link
  • ☐ Valid physical address included
  • ☐ Email authentication properly implemented
  • ☐ No misleading headers or routing information
  • ☐ Clear identification as advertisement if applicable
  • ☐ Tested on major email clients
  • ☐ Mobile-responsive design

Summary​

Email marketing compliance isn't just about following rules—it's about building trust with your audience while protecting your brand reputation. Here's what you need to remember:

  • Get Clear Permission: Always obtain proper consent before sending marketing emails. This builds trust and improves engagement metrics.
  • Make Leaving Easy: Honor unsubscribe requests promptly and make the process simple. People who don't want your emails aren't good prospects anyway.
  • Be Transparent: Clearly identify yourself, be honest about your content, and never try to mislead recipients. Transparency builds long-term relationships.
  • Protect Your Sending Reputation: Implement proper authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) to prevent spoofing and ensure your legitimate emails reach the inbox.
  • Know Your Audience's Location: Different regions have different rules. Be aware of which laws apply to your subscriber base and follow the strictest applicable standards.
  • Keep Good Records: Maintain evidence of consent, track preference changes, and document your compliance efforts in case questions arise.
  • Create Clear Processes: Develop standardized procedures for your team to follow to ensure consistent compliance across all campaigns.

Compliance isn't just about avoiding penalties—it's a best practice approach that leads to better email performance, stronger customer relationships, and a healthier bottom line. By respecting your subscribers' choices and privacy, you build a foundation for more effective email marketing.

Additional Resources​